Why the second half of Death Note was dull

There is a general consensus in the Death Note fandom that the second half of the story isn’t as strong as the first.

In fact, I would be so bold as to call it dull.

But why did the cult classic lose its spark after the manga’s shocking turning point?

WARNING – SPOILERS AHEAD

I think it’s because, compared to L, Near was a boring character.

L was an interesting character, not just because he was intelligent, but because he had a fun personality.

He was funny.

One of my favourite scenes is from Chapter 32 where L steals Misa’s phone, but in the process he touches her butt, but feigns innocence in a witty way. Just look at that facial expression in the second panel.

1

Then he goes onto to troll Light, knowing he would use Misa to find out his real name in order to kill him. His expression in the third panel is priceless.

1-1

In contrast, Near doesn’t have any humorous moments. All the comedy after the time skip comes from either Ryuk or Matsuda.

It was easy to sympathize with L.

The whole reason L failed to capture Light was that he began to see them as friends. It was hard for him to believe that his first friend was the bad guy he had been chasing after, and I think he didn’t want to bring Light to justice because it would mean he would lose his one and only friend.

1-2

On the other hand, we never see Near pining after anything except bringing Kira to justice. Mello is a more sympathetic character in this respect because we see his desire to beat Near.

1 (3).jpg

We feel for Mello because he is an underdog, and for L for finally finding that one friend. But Near seems to have no weakness or soft spot we can empathize  with.

Near was L’s copy cat

Because L was such a unique character, it was a delight to have someone new to observe as Death Note progressed. His mannerisms, speech patterns, intelligence and eating habits were interesting because there had never been a character before who processed them. He was a breath of fresh air to the literary world.

61c57e67-5c1e-48bd-8d65-974848c826f7_l.jpg

In contrast, Near’s habits were an exact copy of L’s – apart from his love of toys; Mello seems to have inherited L’s sweet tooth. The main difference is that Near is less quirky. It was a disappointment to get someone so similar to L, yet so much less interesting after L’s death.

The story line for Death Note also got a little more complicated and confusing in the second half, which might contribute to that lack of spark after L’s death. There was tension in the air as the series began to wind down, but there were a lot of new characters and a lot of stalling for time. The tension built very slowly since most of the plot focused on the members of Light’s team as they started to have doubts.

But I think that lack of spark was lost because L’s shoes were filled with someone with a lot less substance. A lot of the plot problems could have perhaps been solved by having a new interesting rival for Light, rather than the flat, emotionless character we got in the form of Near.

Did you find the second half of Death Note less exciting? If so, do you think having a more interesting rival for Light could have solved some of the problems?

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Why the second half of Death Note was dull

  1. On rewatch I generally just stop watching after L is defeated. Or I skip to the final couple of episodes. Near and Mello just don’t interest me and while I do want to see Light defeated (it is quite interesting) the build up to this isn’t fun to watch. Still, watching it once is fine as the overall story remains compelling.

    Like

  2. I can understand why L is defeated from a shock perspective, but from an entertainment perspective, it’s just bad. Plus then having someone (well, someones) try to be a “L-lite” kind of makes the whole shock seem pointless.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s